← All posts

I Tested Walmart's $35 Thanksgiving Deal. Here's How It Stacks Up Against Aldi

Aldi's $39 dinner for 10 came in at $36.67. Walmart says it can do it for $35. I bought every item to see which one really wins.

Last week I bought Aldi's $39 Thanksgiving dinner for 10 and thought it was the deal of the year. Then I found out Walmart has one too: same idea, feeds 10 people, and it's $35. Cheaper doesn't always mean better, so I went to see for myself and put it right next to Aldi's.

Same three rules as Aldi

  • Everything comes straight off Walmart's list. If something's out of stock, I grab the closest swap and tell you what it cost.
  • I can't spend more than $40, tax included. If I go over, something goes back.
  • It has to be a real Thanksgiving: a main, sides and dessert for 10 people.

What's in Walmart's cart

The first thing I noticed: Walmart's vegetables are canned, where Aldi's were frozen. The list had three cans of corn, three cans of green beans, cream of mushroom soup, crispy onion topping, sweet potatoes, a 5-pound bag of russet potatoes, a dozen dinner rolls for $1, two boxes of stuffing, gravy mix, pumpkin puree, two corn muffin mixes, marshmallows, evaporated milk, a two-pack of pie crusts, whipped topping, cranberries and a Butterball turkey.

Two things were out of stock, so I made swaps. The $1 fried onion topping became crispy onions for $2.78, and the brown gravy mix became turkey gravy for 78 cents. Walmart's price is based on about a 13½-pound bird, but I grabbed a 15.86-pound turkey to keep it close to my Aldi turkey.

A tip I loved: in the Walmart app, you can tap "flash price tag" on an item, and a little light blinks on the shelf where it is. That saved me more than once.

Round by round

Turkey: Aldi. Walmart gives you a name-brand Butterball, but my Aldi turkey was almost a full pound bigger. That's leftovers and turkey sandwiches on Friday.

Sides: Walmart. Walmart basically hands you a menu: green bean casserole, mashed potatoes and gravy, sweet potatoes with marshmallows, cornbread, stuffing, rolls, cranberries and two kinds of potatoes. Aldi gave me a few fresher things, like celery, carrots, peas and milk, but Walmart put more dishes on the table.

Dessert: Aldi. Neither pie is ready to go. Walmart gives you plain pumpkin, so you add the sugar, spices and eggs yourself, though its crust comes in its own pan. Aldi gave me real heavy cream instead of a frozen tub, so I can make real whipped cream.

Also check the fine print. Walmart pickup or delivery can add a fee of up to $19.95, and out-of-stock swaps change your total. Check the app before you go and get there early.

The real totals

On paper, Walmart says $35 and Aldi says $39. What I actually paid: Aldi $36.67, Walmart $39.26. I went over Walmart's $35 because of the two swaps and the bigger turkey, but I stayed under $40, so nothing went back. That's only about $2.60 more than Aldi.

My verdict: if you want the most food, go to Walmart. If you want something a little easier to make, go to Aldi. Either way, both feed 10 people for under $4 a person, and both stores deserve credit this year.

A deal is one day. Hunger is every day.

A family of four on SNAP gets at most about $34 a day. So even Walmart's $35 Thanksgiving, the cheapest one out there, costs more than a whole day of food for that family. And that's if they still have SNAP. Here in Nebraska, almost 33,000 fewer people are on SNAP than a year ago, and about half of them are kids.

So here's my ask this week: if you can, grab one extra thing for your local food pantry. A box of stuffing is under $2. If you're in Nebraska and lost SNAP, Nebraska Appleseed can help. If you missed it, read my Aldi $39 Thanksgiving post, where I go deeper on what's happening with SNAP.

Are you team Aldi or team Walmart? And what's the one side dish that has to be on your table or it's not Thanksgiving? Tell me in the video's comments.

Watch on YouTube Join the conversation in the comments
keep reading

More from the blog

don't miss the next one

Join the Breaking Point family

New videos every Friday at 4 PM CT and a live show every Sunday at 7 PM CT.

Subscribe on YouTube